Wednesday, 17 July 2013

My son, my son , What have ye done? (2009), Genre: Drama/Thriller, Runtime: 88 minutes, 2/5



Supposedly based on real events, this is the story of a son who does something abominable to his mother (The last words of the mother have been taken as the title of the movie). 

Shot on a budget which seems to have been lesser than the cost of a shoe string, this begins with two cops (William Defoe, playing a veteran on the force and Michael Pena,a novice) getting a call informing that a crime has been committed in their vicinity. They rush out to the area, find neighbors surrounding a house and meet a mysterious man (Michael Shannon) who chants some mambo jumbo and then walks off to the neighboring house. He is soon recognized as the prime suspect and the rest of the duration of the movie deals with police’s attempts to bring him out of the hiding place and Citizen Kane like reconstruction of Michael Shannon’s life by his fiance and friend.

Herzog, for me, is one of the very few directors whose very name on a DVD’s spine makes my heart race. My love affair with his work started after watching Bad Lieutenant wherein he nearly single handedly resurrected Nicholas Cage’s career. My respect for him grew leaps and bounds after watching his other masterpiece Aguirre: the wrath of God, Rescue Dawn and The Enigma of Kaspar Hauser. Hence, I had high hopes from this.

These hopes were further raised by the fact that David Lynch, the God of surrealistic cinema was the producer. This was supposed to be a fusion of two great minds and hence my expectations became sky high. 

Alas, soon they came crashing down with a thud.

This is a combination of police procedural with the cops trying to get Shannon to surrender and mystical scenes which show how Shannon’s thought process began to change after a visit to Peru. However, at times it seems too pretentious for its own good and alienates the viewer with its un-involving narrative. 

The one front wherein this doesn’t disappoint is the acting with Shannon again doing his “intense” stuff brilliantly. He is one of the best actors around and whenever he is on the screen, the watcher cannot look anywhere else, glued as he is to the magnetic charisma which Shannon exudes. The others have two bit roles and are generally wasted.

This is the fourth consecutive misfire on the movie front for me this month and is very nearly on top of “The movies which I would love missing even if I am paid a million dollars to watch” list. Watch it at your own risk.

No comments:

Post a Comment